Before I start troubleshooting with gauges I check to see if the gauges that are installed have been calibrated within the last year. I look for a sticker on the back of the gauge with a calibration date on it. If the plant does not calibrate its gauges of the particular gauge is out of calibration I do a quick accuracy check of the gauge. To do this I carry with me two adjustable wrenches, a couple of small (2") but high quality gauges to use as test gauges, and whatever PPE is appropriate for the environment you are working in and fluid you are working with.
If the gauge is found to be accurate I will use it for troubleshooting. If not I replace the gauge if I have a new one handy or continue my troubleshooting using my test gauges and put in arequest to have the bad gauge replaced. If you must leave the bad gauge in place it is good to mark it as being inaccurate so that others know not to trust its readings.